The controversial reinvention of the Mini was blamed on BMW – but it turned out to be a winner
When BMC launched the original Mini in 1959, it was both highly innovative in its packaging and widely affordable, being priced from just £496 – and of course it was wildly successful.
Come the early 1990s, its new custodian, Rover, began exploring a replacement – but when BMW bought the British company in January 1994, it was clear that they had very different ideas about what a new Mini should look like.
Development quickly became a tug of war. Rover proposals favoured a compact, innovatively packaged successor, while BMW proposals leaned towards a retro-styled sporting car. Fifteen different designers from across Europe and the US were tasked with designing the new car in just six months, ultimately presenting various competing visions – creating real tension.
BMW eventually settled on a strategy of repositioning the Mini from a budget car into a premium car, choosing a design proposal by its own Frank Stephenson.
It would target two distinct demographics: affluent young “thrusters” between the ages of 20 and 34 and those aged 35-50 who had fond memories of the original Mini. And it would be 20 times more expensive: the One ultimately started at £10,000 and the sporty Cooper at £11,600.
Our first glimpse of this direction came at the Frankfurt motor show in 1997, three years before the car’s release, as BMW wanted to gauge public reaction. There were risks in exposing the design so early, but chairman Bernd Pischetsrieder dismissed those worries, insisting that “nobody will copy the Mini; it will be a unique car”.
Reaction was anything but unified. One Autocar reader complained: “As a long-standing Mini owner and admirer, I was pleasantly surprised to hear that BMW planned to give the world a sneak preview. Until I saw it. This is not a Mini; everything that the Mini stands for has been bastardised into a pointless marketing gimmick.” Another snapped back: “New Mini? Honey, I shrunk the Citroën DS.”
Even Alex Moulton, the engineer responsible for the original Mini’s suspension, expressed disapproval, telling Autocar: “I don’t know what it is. It’s got the word Mini on it, and details such as the grille and lights are right, but the car is too large. It looks like it has lost its proportions. I don’t think it’s a real Mini.”
Accusations of BMW ruining the Mini’s classic look also rolled in, with one reader writing: “Those lights, that grille – especially if spun round the other way. Yes, old frog eyes is back! One of the ugliest faces to deface a car (last seen in the Ford Scorpio) makes a return.” Another struggled to believe that the prototype unveiled at Frankfurt was a new Mini in spirit and not “a cynical attempt to market what appears to be just another small hatch by trading on the name, reputation and styling cues of the greatest car of all time”.
Not all responses were hostile, though, as this letter demonstrates: “I’m smitten. The new Mini has shot to the top of my new car shopping list. It combines the need for extra space and safety, with just the right mix of retro styling cues and modern layout.”
When the new Mini finally went on sale in 2001, our road testers found it “great to look at and sit in” but felt that wasn’t enough to offset such a “mediocre engine and disappointing package”. Like the earlier public reaction, this was a verdict of contrasts: eager and engaging to drive yet lumbered with an engine that felt coarse and gruff.
To buy such a car also meant stepping into a BMW dealership, which one reader described as an “intimidating experience”. This highlighted a deeper tension: Mini was no longer accessible and classless but a carefully curated premium product, and not everyone was comfortable with that shift.
Enjoy full access to the complete Autocar archive at the magazineshop.com
In reinventing the Mini, BMW had taken a risk by trading simplicity for sophistication and affordability for aspiration. Predictably, not everyone liked this idea, but plenty more bought into it: 800,000 examples of the Mk1 were sold globally, and today Stephenson’s design is widely regarded as a modern classic.
Furthermore, the Mini grew into a thriving brand with a broad model range – in stark contrast to Rover, which died in 2005.
Alice Pewter
